Let me just start off by saying I'm not even going to delve into how laggy matches are, the poor net code, or the input delays. I want to talk about how in Smash Ultimate you have no way to have matchmaking guarantee you that you will play the mode you selected in your preferred/requested rules.
In Smash Wii U, they split up two different modes, for fun and for glory. For glory allowed you to play 1v1 ranked games, no items, two stock, and stages were set to final destination. Not the best system but it worked well enough for those of us who wanted to try and hone our skills in competitive smash without stage hazards or items or free for all games. In smash ultimate, you can REQUEST to play 1v1 games, but their matchmaking system decides the majority of the time that, nah fuck it, youre going to play 4 player free for all, all items on, stage hazards. At first I thought this was an unintentional bug, something that could just be patched quickly once they figured out what the problem was. Turns out that this system is working exactly as intended and youre at the whim of the smash MM system as to whether its going to allow you to play the mode you want to play online. Even better, there doesn't seem to be a quit button to leave these matches and I assume just turning the console off will result in some form of punishment for leaving matches (matches you dont even want to play). To put this into perspective, imagine Bo4 having this system. "Hey I want to play a game of zombies for fun just to relax" but instead youre plopped into a hardcore death match game with no way to leave and are punished if you do. Its like if Master chief collection was working properly at launch instead of being a buggy mess. "Oh you wanted to play BTB but are now playing doubles? No thats intentional, you can only request to play the mode that it is you wish to play".
I understand expectations shouldn't be high. I assume a lot of people are going to ask "but what did you expect?" and my answer to that is, at the very least, have what you had with the wii u so I can actually play the modes I want to play instead of getting stuck in these laggy 4 player free for all messes. I also understand that its par for the course for Nintendo to be this far behind for online gaming in 2018 because everyone seemingly gives them a pass, but this is one of their flagship titles, with sales breaking records. How do you launch, intentionally, a system this poor for 60 dollars? How? Its inexcusable.