Winterfury
fun^10*int^40=Ir2
- Iscritto dal
- 8 Lug 2009
- Messaggi
- 6,466
- Reazioni
- 251
Offline
Sto rileggendo Umineko e ho una domanda (Spoilerone di Chiru, attenzione):
Ma non è una contraddizione che,nel primo episodio, trovino Shannon morta nel capanno ma allo stesso tempo Kanon sia vivo e vegeto e interagisca con loro?
------------------------First Twilight---
---------------------
-Description:
Six bodies were found in the tool-shed, their faces smashed apart, with a magic circle on the shutter. The six were Krauss, Kyrie, Rudolf, Godha, Rosa and Shannon. Out of the six, only Shannon was surely identified thanks to her ring. The shed was locked by a key that was in the servants' quarters.
-Red Truths:
#1: "the identities of all unidentified corpses are guaranteed (Used by Lambdadelta in ????? for Episode 1.)"
-Explanation:
The method of the murder is irrelevant. Based on the blood-stains in the dining hall, the actual killing caused only minor bleeding, so it was either a relatively small stab wound, or, more likely, blunt force trauma directly to the head. Death by shooting is also possible, and while it would fit Yasu's MO better, it would have caused more bleeding. Either way, the end result is the same.
-Further Details:
The faces were destroyed to protect Yasu's identity as Shannon/Kanon and to keep the modus operandi consistent. It is also notable that neither George (the person closest to her who was not in on the murders) nor Battler (our only reliable narrator) have seen her face, only Hideyoshi.
However, it is quite possible that Eva and Hideyoshi are forced or bribed into becoming Yasu's accomplices at this point (more on that below), thus it is not only possible that Hideyoshi lied and Shannon's corpse weren't even there, but highly probable.
The funniest thing though is that the Red Truth regarding unidentified corpses specifically allows Shannon's corpse to be non-guaranteed. One one hand, it is described as being only half-smashed and thus she was not "unidentified" (plus the ring provided clear identification). On the other hand, there was no unidentified *corpse* to begin with (as in, Yasu was either still alive or there was no body at all at the scene). In short, Yasu dodges the Red not once but twice!
-Special Circumstances:
Maria's involvement was made especially obvious by the magic circle, which was more than likely drawn by her on the first place, thus explaining why she knew so much about it. The same goes for all the other magic symbols throughout the episode. The circumstances relating to the shed's key and the locked mansion doors are irrelevant, as the servants have the keys for both.
1234